SAGADA
MOUNTAIN PROVINCE- Host dap-ay Malingebhas a
new look witnessed on the conduct of the annual Tangeb di Babayas (closing of
wedding celebrations) or Begnas di Tangeb di Ogas (closing of the rice harvest season) last July
22 by dumap-ay (members) of the 12 dap-ay of central Sagada.
A
roofing made of insulated anahaw, two giant statues by the front side, painted
walls and an extended mosaic designed dance floor with eight mandalas that
intrigued the Sagada public.
A
different look from what it was before it got remodeled recently this second
quarter of the year, the dap-ay was then made of GI roofing, unpainted cement
walls and no giant statues at the front side.
The GI roofed dap-ay in the ‘90s replaced the older dap-ay made of ‘gu-un’ (cogon) roofing
and wooden plank walling. Said replacement was then a project of the then Office
of National Cultural Communities (ONCC) before it was nationally called
National Commission of Indigenous Peoples (NCIP).
Sagada
which must have been of cogonal terrain before the American Period, ‘gu-un’(cogon)
was the material used for the construction of dwellings before as noted in old pictures.‘Gu-un’ must have been the material used in
the making of dap-ay Malingeb the first dap-ay by Biag, the legendary founder
of Sagada. And/or it may have been other
indigenous material then at that time.
And,
the first dap-ay must have been a much smaller hut than its size now but as
years went by and changes of replacing the ‘gu-un’ went by must have increased a
little bit bigger till it reached its size now, surmised Irenius Tauli, elder
of dap-ay Malingeb, in an interview.
And
so it was told that Biag came from Bika, from the hinterlands of eastern Abra then went to the Ilocos to avoid
invasion of headhunters. Not wanting to be Christianized, Biag found his way to
Sagada and established the first dap-ay in Malingeb followed by dap-ay Bilig
and Pikong in Demang built by his two children Bandowa and Konyap and eight
others in the old settlements of Dagdag and Demang and eventually one in
barangay Patay.
And so other dap-ay were built by others as Biag found three
men- Ganga, Peng-as and Puse- when he
first came to Sagada before the Spanish period said elders Jaime Timpac , Jesse
Pelayo from dap-ay Maballayand Joseph Guitilen
Capuyan from dap-ay Lukong of Demang.
And so it
was noted that the climate then was coldand so was built a low lying hut for sleeping quarters called ‘abong’
built near the ‘amlangan’ section where the stone-seats and ‘padao’ (totem poles) were firmly planted. The
‘padao’ signified that heads of invading buso (headhunters) from other places
were cut off by ‘dumap-ay’ warriors and these hung on the poles to signify victory.
The
sleeping quarters called ‘abong ‘ and the ‘amlangan’ compose the dap-ay. And
men would come together from time to time to commune and talk about important
ili concerns while warming themselves around a bonfire.
The
dap-ay embeds the culturalfabric of
economic, social, political and educational activities done in theimmediate ili (community). For one, when the
begnas, an agricultural feastis
decidedwhen it shall happen among
otheractivities.
The
young boys learned values of respect to elders, honesty, industry, and ‘inayan’
or ‘lawa’ are inculcated to them while they do chores such as gathering
firewood to keep the fire burning at night or massage the feet of older men
using sticks in a foot massage called ‘kolkolis’.
‘Inayan’
is the indigenous interpretation of the universal saying/teaching of Jesus
Christ to “do unto others what you like others do unto you”. For it is ‘inayan’ not
to do harm to another lest harm shall befall any member of the family when harm
is done to another.
Sukyab
From time
to time the weathered roofing of the dap-ay got replaced with fresh ‘gu-un’ as done in a
practice called ‘sukyab’ or ‘sekyab’ for the new ‘gu-un’ to prevent rain from
seeping inside the sleeping quarters.
A
practice that got ignored or not anymore practiced as the dap-ay roofing was
changed to GI sheets by ONCC in the ‘90s.
Elders
Guitilen Capuyan of dap-ay Lukong of Demang, Jesse Pelayo and Jaime Timpac of
dap-ay Maballay of Dagdag said many of the dap-ay of central Sagada then had
been burned by matchstick- playing children before these were changed to GI
sheets and wooden walls to concrete.
Other
dap-ay in other parts of Sagada had also been changed to GI sheet roofing and cemented
walls.
So
for quite some time, the practice to ‘mensukyab’ got ignored with already
installed GI sheet roofing of the 12 dap-ay of central Sagada.And must be so with other dap-ay of the whole
town where the roofing had been changed to GI sheets.
The
dap-ay of the old settlement of Fidelisan of northern Sagada has also been
changed to GI sheet roofing.
What
more, ‘gu-un’ is ‘manmanu’ (not so much to find) much as cows graze the
mountains and these burned with the occurrence of forest fires, elder Archie
Sumedca of dap-ay Matuba of Dagdag said.
With the
equally persistent burning of mountains and the changing of flora into other
plants and trees, cogon has been not so visible in the mountainsides not only
in Sagada but in other mountainous areas as well.
Though
Forester Christopher Bosaing of the Community Environment Natural Resources Office(CENRO)
said there is still cogon but these do not grow long due to the burning of
mountains.
Comes now
Malingeb having opted to change the GI roofing to anahaw sourced from warm
weathered Pagudpud, Ilocos Norte and Quezon province.
Anahaw
is more durable with a 20-year life span as compared to a 5-year durability of ‘gu-un’
before it shall be changed again said Aldwin Ayban a dumap-ay of Malingeb and
who supervised the replacement to anahaw roofing.
And
to prevent the anahaw from fire threats, the material was covered with
insulated net, Ayban added.
A
much commented issue in social media, changing of the roof to anahaw stirred
the question of what ‘heritage’ means with some sending the question of why not
use ‘gu-un’.
Anahaw is
‘ananga’ in our dialect, that material which people in our place then used to
cover their heads and back from the rain, Tauli added.
Anahaw
gets ‘closer to what heritage means”, he added.
Heritage
With the
advocacy of and legislative enactions passed in national laws and local
ordinances on heritage, a conscious query on what is heritage prompts people to
know what the ‘old’ is to be preserved.
The
question on what was the traditional material of the dap-ay roofing came in
time with the recent passing of the heritage ordinance on man-made structures
by the Sangguniang Bayan of the municipality of Sagada as approved by the
Sangguniang Panlalawigan and transmitted to the SB on June 25 this year.
The
SB defined ‘heritage’ as the “traditions, achievements, beliefs, culture and
the like that are part of the history of a group, community or nation”; and
man-made structures to strictly refer “to any building or edifice either made
of stone, wood, grass or materials or any combination thereof intended either
as family or public shelter, community congregation, and or gathering coupled
with the noble intentions of its use and purpose.”
As
broad as it is defined, heritage includes the intangible aspect of the culture
of a people distinguished from the tangible physical structure which is the
material form.
Purist-
critic netizens from Sagada say the cogon or gu-un roofing of the dap-ay has to
be preserved. And that there should be no changes in the roofing, walling, and
everything of it. For that structure shall tell what heritage of what it was
before. For indeed, what is a story to tell if there is no historical structure
to see.
Former
Sagada vice mayor Richard Yodong suggests that one structure be restored to
have the look of the old ‘gu-un’ roofed dap-ay so to refer to what materially
was the historical structure before the dap-ay now were replaced to GI sheet roofing
and anahaw. Yodong exhorts on the responsibility of the dumap-ay to look after the upkeep of their respective dap-ay. Among the 12 dap-ay of central Sagada, some are dilapidated while others are maintained. Some are visited most of the time while others obviously are abandoned by the look of the dilapidated abong itself or some celllophane wrappers strewn at the dap-ay's pantew (frontyard). One needs physical relocation for the dap-ay to be moved away from a curve at the roadside as it shows hazardous location as noticed elder Guitilen of dap-ay Lukong of Demang.
The
Heritage Act of 2009 or RA 10066 differentiated tangible from intangible
culture. Said Act
referred “tangible cultural property” to cultural property with historical,
archival, anthropological, archaeological, artistic and architectural value,
and with exceptional or traditional production, whether of Philippine origin or
not, including antiques and natural history specimens with significant value.
Tangible
cultural property includes ‘built heritage” to refer to "architectural and
engineering structures such as, but not limited to, bridges, government
buildings, houses of ancestry, traditional dwellings, quartels, train stations,
lighthouses, small ports, educational, technological and industrial complexes,
and their settings, and landscapes with notable historical and cultural
significance."
Much
commented issue in social media heavily participated by netizens from Sagada
and other members in three Facebook group accounts- Save Sagada, Sagada Dap-ayan and Sagada Reports- was the use of anahaw vs the use of traditional cogon as
the roofing, and the stone flooring of the extended section to remain rather
than a flooring with a designed mosaic.
Here,
the intangible cannot be separate from what is tangible considering the nature
of what is being questioned- that of the dap-ay or abong which houses the
sleeping quarters and educational space for young boys which as obviously seen
is integral in the overall meaning of dap-ay.
With
the change of‘gu-un’ to anahaw has
raised spirited questions of “ay waday dap-ay di Ilocano” (is there a dap-ay of
Ilocanos) overheard from young boys who were heavily discussing in a store.
Restoration
being a vital part of ‘conservation” refer to “all the processes and measures
of maintaining the cultural significance of a cultural property including, but
not limited to, preservation, restoration, reconstruction, protection, adaptation
or any combination thereof by the Heritage Act of 2009.”
Where
an old material has weathered and where that old material may not be available
anymore goes into practical remedies such as the availability of GI sheet or anahaw bringing up
the question of what is the extent of restoration.
Throughout
varied periods in time, availability and practicality of materials had been
demonstrated in the restoration of the dap-ay roofing from ‘gu-un’ to GI sheets
to anahaw.
Should there
have been GI sheets in the olden times, such may have been used as roofing of the
dap-ay, elder BisogongBadongen of dapay
Maballay said.
Sagada
elder and writer Benjamin Longid says ‘depending on how it is rendered, the
dap-ay can be not too far a departure from the past while providing space for
its present functions. A table miniature of an old dap-ay can be made to
educate the younger generation and visitors so they can have an idea of that
simple institution that has helped shape our values.”
Nethertheless,
Malingeb elder and former Sagada mayor Thomas Killip emphasize the
strengthening by the community of the “intangible role or function of the
dap-ay referring to values system, traditional rituals, practices, social
gatherings even if the physical look of the dap-ay is changed’
“Intangible
cultural heritage” as defined by the Heritage Act refers to the practices,
representations, expressions, knowledge and skills, as well as the instruments,
objects and artifacts associated therewith, that communities, groups and
individuals recognize as part of their cultural heritage, such as oral
traditions, languages and expressions; performing arts; social practices,
rituals and festive events; knowledge and practices concerning nature and the
universe; and traditional craftsmanship.”
To
this differentiate from “intangible cultural property” to refer to the peoples’
learned processes along with the knowledge, skills and creativity that inform
and are developed by them, the products they create and the resources, spaces
and other aspects of social and natural context necessary for their
sustainability.
And
so the people of Sagada practice their cultural ways since then passed down by
elders who actually performed these. One of which is the begnas, an
agricultural feast capped with playing of gongs and dancing.
Though
for this July begnas called Begnas di Tangeb di Babayas does not customarily observe
dancing as done in the other begnas celebrations.
In
the pursuit of cultural preservation, “the nation’s cultural heritage, its
property and histories, and the ethnicity of local communities shall likewise
endeavor to create a balanced atmosphere where the historic past coexists in
harmony with modern society. It shall approach the problem of conservation in
an integrated and holistic manner, cutting across all relevant disciplines and
technologies."
“Artistic
imagination can be given free rein but within the framework of conservation for
posterity, shouldn’t that be of primary consideration?” exhorts Benjamin Longid, a descendant of Ganga yas Labanet (AGL) one of the old
family- ancestries of Sagada.
And with a relatively new
heritage ordinance of the municipality considering the issues raised in the
innovations done by dap-ay Malingeb, raises queries on implementing rules of
the code or ammending the heritage code itself for one, on what alteration means or who
is the ‘proper authority’ in deciding what restoration or improvement of a
cultural structure is.
The Umbon
The ‘dumap-ay’
per dap-ay are obligated to take care of their own dap-ay either when to ‘sukyab’
their roofing or come together and decide on issues that affect them.
This
including where to get support from projects they want to do with their dap-ay
and other activities they want conducted.
And
so upon request by the Malingeb ‘umbon’ to businessman Alfonso ‘Boy’ Yuchengco
Jr, long-time friend of Sagada, the ‘umbon’ asked for support for the
installation of the anahaw roofing of the abong and the enhancement of the
extended dance floor.
Commonly called
Boyu, Boy Yuchengco Jr is the son of philanthropist - businessman Alfonso
Yuchengco who supported the building of the new St Mary’s School in 1979 after
the old pine wood-made school was razed in1975.
How
the restoration came about emphasized the role of the ‘umbon’ or the ‘pangbon’
referring to the ‘dumap-ay’ or members of the dap-ay.
Aptly,
as Demang elder and tourist guide Aklayan Aben said “ay daida baw” (its up to them) or elder
Badongen of dap-ay Maballay of Dagdag said, “sha met nan ikkan da” referring to
the umbon of Malingeb's consensual agreement when asked on their comment on the
replacement of the roof material to anahaw.
The
‘umbon’ for three consecutive times since the early months of the second quarter
of the year had to come together and discuss the changes that happened, Tauli recalled.
Consultation
being a prime and fundamental requirement on what happens in the dap-ay is a
conscious practice to follow for the dap-ay is a collective composition of the ‘dumap-ay’.
Changing
the roofing,the look of the frontage and the walling, and working on the floor
mosaic was left to the decision of the ‘umbon’ to decide following the
consensus method of coming up with a collective decision.
‘Nu
ngan nan kanan nan tapina et sha nan maikkan’ ( what others say shall it be),
said elder Jaime Capuyan, thereby placing great emphasis on what others say
rather than what only one says.
For
indeed, a dap-ay member from another dap-ay in Sagada or from another place to
dictate or interfere in the affairs of a dap-ay not their own is frowned upon
to follow cultural sovereignty and respect to another.
Where,
as the colors and designs of tapis or wanes have their separate distinction
from another culture or tribe so are decisions of one tribe as to their
sovereign own.
And
shall the municipality’s heritage ordinance qualify criteria of what heritage
means? Tauli who is himself the secretary of Sangguniang Bayan of Sagada said,
let ‘heritage’ stay as how it is worded and to be particularly qualified by respective
members of the dap-ay.
So
does that include the changing of the low lying one storey dap-ay structure now
to a two- story building in the future for example to mean heritage?
“That
would be a different building then”, Tauli said.
And
what about those two big statues at the front side of the dap-ay?
Demang
elder Joseph Guitilen Capuyan frowned on the sculptured human forms at the
front side saying he has never seen ‘tinagtago’ (sculptured human forms) at the
front side of a dap-ay.And for wall paintings?“kigad das sa” (that’s up to them”), he
quipped.
Malingeb
elder Jaime Capuyan has a different opinion on the placing of the statueat the front side of the dap-ay, saying in
dialect,‘dati tako ay buso” (we are
former headhunters).
The
human form statues symbolically guard the dap-ay and the ili (community) from
invaders.
And
so history and the present says, the dap-ay locates the ‘padao’ placed in a
circular arrangement where the cut-off heads of invading headhunters from other
places were hung.
The
heads cut off by warriors and placed in totem poles was the practice during the
head hunting days in Sagada, Bontoc, other places of Mountain Province, Abra,
Kalinga and Ifugao. The cut-off heads placed in totem poles meant victory and
that the ili shall be protected from invaders.
“The
elders told us that the dap-ay itself where the ‘padao’ and the stone-seats are
located should remain as is”, local artist James Wandag said.
And
so the sacred part of the dap-ay remained as is, the padao and stone-seats
intact as how these originally looked like.
The
not so sacred part of the dap-ay referring to the extended dance floor was left
to the imagination of artists who worked on the mosaic designed flooring.
Said
flooring was a former pigsty eventually backfilled with river stones and levelled
to become the dance floor.
Malingeb
elder Jaime Capuyan sees there is nothing wrong with the mosaic saying “baken
dakes’ (not bad) except that the carabao horns installed on the wall of the
dance floor be taken down as there was no babayas (wedding celebration) that
ever happened in dap-ay Malingeb.
Though
other members of the dap-ay look at it differently.Elder and barangay captain Edward Ayban said
there was a time that lakay Omaweng, elder of Mallingeb dap-ay butchered two
carabaos in the 1960s and hung these in one part of the dap-ay in observance of
the ‘goliweng’.
Asked
what ‘goliweng’ is Lakay Guitilen from nearby Demang recalled a star-like
object which went on circular motions with a clanging sound installed high
above one section of the dap-ay and for what purpose he did not know.
The Mosaic
The extended
dance floor with designs of earth elements- sun, moon, plants, sky, waters,
cultural artifacts and man- incorporated tiles and paint on the mosaic worked on
a cemented flooring June this year.
Surrounded
by eight mandalas in a circular pattern surrounding the shape of a lizard enclosed
a ‘wising’-shaped geometric pattern enclosing a blue shaped circle signifying
the earth and sky.
Called
collaborative art by artist Bong Sanchez from Bauko and married to one from
Ambasing, Sagada the work was done with other members of dap-ay Malingeb namely
local artists James Wandag who co-conceptualized the mosaic. Other local
artists and members of Malingeb came in to help namely Aspil Capuyan, Puclis
Guitilen, with the two children ofEril Bistoguey
helped in grouting the mosaic with tiles and Sanchez and Wandag in painting the
designs.
Curves
and lines make up the mosaic with meanings etched in motifs mostly of which are
earth elements, cultural artifacts and man.
Around
the central mandala is a wider shape showing the cultural ‘wising’ the sign for fertility. And so man and woman was created after the heaven and
earth were made by God. Wising was commonly used as an earring used by elders in the past.
Malingeb
known to be a dap-ay for the ‘mamaleng-ag’ or the ‘mamakedse’ is commonly
referred to as the dap-ay of businessmen and perfectly, as the wising is
traditionally made of gold which means wealth.
Around
the wising is the form of a lizard which symbolizes longevity.
Etched
around the lizard form are eight mandalas signifying one set of gongs
culturally played by men during occasions as begnas.
Local
artist James Wandag said the eight gong mandalas speak of harmony and
resounding impact when all played as a collective team. In popular numerology,
eight speaks of dynamism and balance.
The
traditional gong instruments are played during occasions mostly during joyful
events- begnas, weddings, dangtey, and in contemporary times when there are
graduations, conferences, meetings.
The
‘balbeg’ (spear) with its pointed arrow to the
blue form in the middle of mosaic refers to direction- to earth and sky with
the base of the arrow at the back of the head of a person with outstretched
arms praising a higher being. Sagada culture worships Kabunian, local term for
God.
Sanchez
said the person is reclining on the pole of a spear which finds below the
figure of two persons in two separate round geometric shapes colored blue aquatic
waters and green agriculture. Elements which naturally compose the spiritual
and economic life of the Sagada Igorot.
On
the same handle of the spear towards the base of the motif is a ‘kalasag’ (shield)
showing man and his cultural ways with linear motiffs of earth elements, cultural
patterns such as weaves, and man all intertwined in what makes a community. Kalasag
signifies defense and aptly, the upright practise and defense on community and
culture.
Sanchez
and Wandag said some mandalas need pronounced enhancement pending ceramic art
works by local potters Siegrid Angway- Rogers and Tessie Baldo.
The
subject ‘understanding culture society and politics’ in senior high school
makes this mosaic a perfect summarized art work of what the subject means, the
beginning of creation, the intertwining weaves of nature with that of man and culture
and valuing the earth.
Another
part of the dance floor is a waiting space where a bench was installed with
sculptured faces on the window part and where other mandalas are found on the
flooring including the popular universal yin-yang symbol. Sculptured art works were done by local artist
and carpenter JessieGaongen.
Though
“one of my favorite images in my personal reflections, the Yin-Yang figure is
misplaced and contributes nothing to affirm the dap-ay's identity”, Longid commented.
The
mosaic in a wider meaning tells the material culture of Sagada. The land is
worked on, waters are crucial in farming, and pigs, chickens and even dogs are offered
to Kabunian for bountiful harvest,
fertility, longevity, prosperity, security and banning of disease.
Like
what elder Jaime Capuyan popularly called Lakay Saime prayed during the Begnas
id Malingeb that the dreaded Covid virus shall not enter Sagada.
Begnas di Tangeb di Babayas
Begnas di
Tangeb di Babayas (wedding celebrations) annually happens July after the Begnas
di Ani (rice harvest in June.
The
July begnas then closes the wedding celebrations done in May and the rice
harvest in June.
Tangeb di
Babayas is an annual event which caps the wedding season culturally held in
May. Though there were no wedding celebrations due to the Covid pandemic, the
begnas event went on as observed along with the Tangeb di Ogas or the closing
of rice harvest.
Begnas
di Tangeb di Babayas comes with Begnas di Latab or Begnas di Ogas (closing of
harvest).
There
are five regular begnas events done the wholeyear round. The first called Begnas di Yabyab is done in November to
signify the start of the rice planting season with the legendary ‘Bangan’ doing
the first rice planting.
Rice
seedlings were planted in December and eventually the ripened palay harvested
June to July.
Begnas
in Sagada is an agricultural feast held five times a year.
Begnas
di Yabyab is followed by the second begnas in March to signify the construction
of houses and milling of sugarcane thus Begnas di Lebek followed in May to
signify Begnas di Tiyagew (dry season) and wedding celebrations.
And
the cycle repeats again in November’s Begnas di Yabyab depending on the phase
of the moon.
During
the Begnas, the men clad in their G- strings and each holding a spear walk the
pathway from river Tudey to the host dap-ay loudly chanting the ‘wawe’, shouts
of men having began their walk from the river to the host dap-ay. Waters
compose an integral essence of the agricultural feast.
The
giving of wine, ‘tupig’ or sticky rice wrapped in sugarcane leaves, bread from
women follow and these materially collected for the dap-ay. From the earth,
earth’s products are offered and the ritual begins.
The
ritual implores Kabunian for health, procreation, longevity, prosperity, and
good harvest for the people of the ili (community).
Malingeb’s new intros
The
replacement of‘gu-un’ to anahaw roofing
is not new on what dap-ay Malingeb has done in the past on its innovations to cite the "goliweng' and now the anahaw roofing and mosaic designed dance floor. What is more to see in the near
future?
James
Wandag envisions the dance floor to serve as an educational workshop site where children can come together and learn what the culture of Sagada is. He
also envisions the newly enhanced extension to serve as a venue where art works
of Sagada artists- both children and adults can display their arts and crafts.
And this to accommodate other dumap-ay of Sagada.
And
so goes the song ‘It’s a new world’ by The Moody Blues.
SAGADA,
MOUNTAIN PROVINCE – “Waay sha san ited presidente ay sag P5,000.00” (Maybe that
is the P5,000 the President (Duterte) shall distribute to the people.”)
“Reinforcement
ngen di Army sa.” (Maybe that’s reinforcement by the Armed Forces of the
Philippines)
These
are some of the reactions of residents here from this tourist town on the dropping
of anti- new people’s army (NPA)- communist party of the Philippines (CPP)-
national democratic front (NDF) propaganda material folded in plastic with a candy
weight from two helicopters on April 12.
Contents
of said leaflet assured people of assistance that government provides at this
time of enhanced community quarantine (ECQ) for affected and poor families due Covid-19.
Believed
to be flown by elements from the Armed Forces of the Philippines
(AFP)/Philippine National Police (PNP), two helicopters hovered over this town
here late morning of Easter Sunday disturbing the residents with repeated
whirrs and leaving cellophane-wrapped flyers on yards, rooftops, trees,
mountains, rivers and streets.
Whirrs
of helicopters bring mixed reactions among residents here in this small town
ever since it was visited by choppers in the ‘70s till now.
Choppers
coming here in the ‘70s are a joy and an excitement among children who rushed
on grounds where the helicopter has landed.
In
different periods of the previous years though, scared residents of the ‘80s
and 90’s are witness to the dropping of bombs along with the hovering of AFP
choppers in their anti-insurgency drives that led to the establishment of a
peace zone in 1993.
Choppers
also meant the coming of former president Gloria Arroyo in the early years of
2000. Arroyo was often a visitor of Sagada which led to the making of the state
of the nation (SONA) projects in the north including the rehabilitation of the
Dantay-Sagada Road.
Choppers
in the recent tourism years when tourism boomed in the 2010 upwards meant rich
people from Manila as the Ayalas’ coming here as tourists. Choppers in the recent Easter Day are a propaganda thing.
The
militant Cordillera Peoples Alliance (CPA) in their statement considers the
incident a “waste of peoples’ money amid lack of economic assistance during the
pandemic.”
In
this period of enhanced community quarantine (ECQ), government assistance comes
in a P200 billion cash and non-cash social amelioration program (SAP) for 18
million Filipinos out of the country’s 104 million population.
Government
assistance programs are Covid adjustment measures program (CAMP) foraffected formal employeesand Tulong pangkabuhayan sa ating displaced
and disadvantaged (TUPAD) workers administered by the department of labor and
employment (DOLE); P5,000 financial aid and P25,000 loan forfarmers in the Department of
Agriculture’sSurvival and Recovery
Assistance (SURE) program; loans to entrepreneurs by the Department of
Trade and Industry (DTI)’s Enterprise Rehabilitation Financing facility under
the Pondo sa Pagbabago at Pag-asenso;and P5,000-P8,000 cash assistance and food relief bythe department of social welfare and development
(DSWD).
The
DSWDis currently distributing the
P5,000 to P8,000 amelioration subsidy to affected and poor families at this ECQ
period while others have not yet availed of the amount with others complaining
of not being qualified as beneficiary.
In
some parts of the country, the distribution of food relief has also received
complaints of some not having reached them while others were given.
Netizens
in their Facebook posts also expressed their disgust on the helicopters
dropping the leaflets as a waste of public funds.
Sagada
resident Gwen Gaongen said, “wishful thinking ay relief ya PPE nan inyali da wenno at least
informative sheets tet ew isnan ikkan di ipugaw ay maka avail sinan government
support idwani ay quarantine. Expensive propaganda moves when many have nothing
to eat” (wishful thinking that relief and protective equipment (PPE) are what
they have brought or at least informative sheets on how to avail of government
support during this quarantine period).
Sagada
resident Botbotanmel Abadsaid, “... Kanan mi pay no kaisagutan nan inbaban da tosa. Aneyna..... ado kasapulan id
waniy panawen. Baken papel ay para ilo. (...We thought it’s something
helpful that they have brought us. Unfortunately, there’s much needed these
days. Not that sheet of paper good for toilet paper.)
CPA
chairperson Windel Bolinget who also comes from Sagada asked, “among other
expenses, how much was spent for the aviation fuel consumed by two helicopters
for more than an hour?”
“These
should have been useful if used for relief operations urgently needed by the
people in this time of lockdown and difficulty” Bolinget added.
Beverly
Longid who comes from Sagada and currently works with the International Indigenous Peoples Movement for Self Determination and Liberation said, “….At this time of the
pandemic, funds should prioritize public health, purchase of much-needed PPEs
for frontlines, relief and economic aid for those in need. Accordingly, HUEY
UH1J Utility choppers as seen here would spend PhP110k per hour airborne. The
government wasted at least PhP200K exclusive the printing of the black
propaganda, the plastic wrapping and candies used as package weight. The amount
could also be used to augment the SAP funds.”
The
AFP has a budget of P192 billion for 2020 and the “PNP of P187 billion to
include in its budget items anti-insurgency operations.
Others
are apprehensive of the leaflets dropped from the choppers.
Sagada
resident Carmen Gayyad in her Facebook post said “Ay ta sat
pai infected is covid 19 nan flyers ya candies ay sana da?.... Ay xa et sa, maawawni daida nan mangidateng c covid 19 cna community
tako. (what if those flyers and candies were infected with covid-19?... Its dreadful to think that they might be the
ones to bring covid-19 in our community.)
While
others demand that those responsible be made accountable. Netizen Felipe Mendoza de Leon said,” the officers and soldiers responsible for
this illegal activity should be investigated and prosecuted for the terrible
waste of resources and act of terrorizing the peaceful communities of Sagada.”
This writer comments violation of free prior and informed consent (FPIC) with the
helicopters having entered the areal territory of Sagada without prior consent; and a violation of one’s rights and invasion
to personal property having dropped candies on private yards and rooftops.
Said
flyers warned the people not to receive relief goods and donations from groups
that they allege to be members of the CPP-NPA.
Earlier,
the CPA a militant organization composed of a number of people’s organizations
wit other activist groups and individuals distributed relief goods in some
communities of Baguio, La Trinidad and Benguet some days ago.
Sagada
resident Steven Edward Rogers said in his Facebook post, “What's being prevented? All
this does is antagonize people. Why spend all that money flying helicopters
when local police could easily distribute flyers? The timing is really poor. I
don't think they are winning any hearts and minds with that. More the opposite.
If they want to get people to trust the government they need performance, not
propaganda.”
Meantime,
Sagada resident Dom-an Macagne was emphatic about "not dropping propaganda materials from
the sky on Easter Sunday."
SAGADA, MOUNTAIN PROVINCE – The heavily opposed controversial diversion road here at the borders of the Mission Compound takes a new argument in favor of opposing petitioners.
“Sagada being underlain by Karst topography may well indicate that the Mission Compound is relatively fragile for major infrastructural development.”
Mining engineer and St Mary’s School alumnus Jerry Abeya in his letter to Bishop Brent Alawas of the Episcopal Diocese of Northern Philippines (EDNP) has this to say regarding the opposed proposed diversion road projected to be built from the Poblacion terminal joining the Dantay-Sagada National Road at the Daoangan section.
Proposed 700 meter road follows a creek along Deccan to Sayocsoc sitios and moves upward below Saint Mary’s School to the borders of private lots and residences of Daoangan.
Above the Deccan-Sayocsoc creek is a sloping area with the softball ground above and the other side of residences built along the opposite slope on to the main road.
While on proposal stage before the Regional Development Council for funding endorsement, petitioners of nearly 300 signatories of Sagada based overseas and nearly 500 signatories from homeland Sagada opposing said proposed diversion road ask congressman Maximo Dalog to withdraw his endorsement and support building of parking spaces instead.
The tourist town of Sagada incurs heavy traffic jams during weekends of holidays when influx of tourists visit the community which boasts of natural beauty spots such as Sumaguing Cave, rice terraces, Bumod-ok and Pongas Falls.
The comment of Abeya posted in Save Sagada Facebook Group was supported by mining engineer and geologist George Tauli who told Abeya, ”you are very right that Sagada is in atop a Karst topography (limestone rocks) so we see all around sinkholes with the most prominent at Kiltepan. Therefore the rocks are very porous and with sinkholes, here and there, that you will never know when to encounter them. In case you intersect one, you cannot imagine how many bags of cement or concrete are needed to fill them up".
"There were instances in recent news around the world that sinkholes swallowed whole buildings and cars along a highway in separate incidents....", Tauli added.
Abeya proposes “a thorough study to be first undertaken by a geology expert to determine any risks a major road could pose to Sagada’s Karst topography in the Mission Compound” while challenging the Episcopal Church in the Philippines (ECP) and the government “to determine in totality if the proposed new diversion road shall strike a harmony between economic development and environment.”
Addressing the Bishop and the Standing Committee who endorsed said road to address traffic issues, Abeya forwarded that “there should be no rush in constructing a major concrete road that could potentially permanently damage the landscape.”
The petitioning public also asked Bishop Alawas to cancel the Permit to Enter signed by him and witnessed by the Barangay Chairman of Patay Poblacion, the Standing Committee, and Department of Public Works and Highways (DPWH) representative to enter, conduct and undertake, survey and occupy and do other construction activities in connection to the building of proposed diversion road.
Opposing Sagadians and parishioners of the Church of St Mary the Virgin would like the Mission Compound to stay as is and are wary of proposed diversion road posing threats of destroying the green belt, indiscriminate waste disposal, and destruction of a heritage site established a hundred years ago. ( Mountain Province Exponent, May 10, 2015)
Please stop this. It derails all efforts on peace building being done.- Ann Lily Uvero, Philippines
I understand how terrible the killing was. I come from Burma and my mother died in 1992. She was kicked, and beaten by the Burmese soldiers. Mon People lived in Burma thousands of year before the arrival of the Burmans. We are treated as animals at our homeland. It is happening the same in Jumma-land. Bangladesh is the same as Burma. Let us stand together for our last stand.- U Ravika,Burma
Bangladesh seriously needs to respect and protect the human rights of indigenous peoples in CHT. The country should take urgent steps to stop encroaching on indigenous peoples land and to punish immediately those responsible in unleasing inhumanity and barbarism at its worst. - Jiten Yumnam, India
We, the indigenous peoples of Indus and tribal of Suleiman Mountains, are seriously concerned on the violence going on against the Jumma peoples and demand the govt of Bangladesh to take notice and do justice with the tribal peoples by acknowledging their right to peace, livelihood and identity.- Wasim Wagha,Pakistan
We at HRCBM are heart broken by the animosity of Bengali settlers and feel that state elements have failed to protect indigenous people of CHT. The allegation of Army’s involvement indicates state’s failure to uphold it’s constitution and it’s obligation under international law. This is an incidental proof of the ongoing genocide that long been ignore by the state as well the international community. It is thus imperative that state be hold responsible for such atrocities.- Dhiman Ded Chowdhury
...it's ETHNIC CLEANSING that is happening in CHT and we want the world to protest against it and protect us from being uprooted from our ancesteral lands. WE NEED YOUR HELP! -Souvik Chakma, CHT, Bangladaesh
We Korean Buddhists are deeply sad by this news. We hope the Government of Bangladesh take necessary actions to fully implement the rights of the Jumma people as soon as possible.- Joo Myonghee, Korea
Not only as a member of an Adibashi community also as a citizen of this country I strongly demand for the justice for the victims and urge all to support us.- Ruby Areng, Bangladesh
This is terrible.Bangladesh government should handle this massacre! - Md. Anisur Rahman, Bangladesh
I can not comprehend the barbarity of your army and plain land settlers on the indegenous people of Chittagong Hill Tracts. As the head of a democratic government you are the responsible person and only you can stop and take action for these heinous acts. Our Jumma people supported all along your party and is this the prize for it Madam Prime Minister? - Dr Bhagadatta Chakma
What happened in 'baghaichhari' is a shame for us as human beings. I personally feel ashamed as a 'Bangalee' as the Bangalee settlers are intruding by any means to lands of indigenous people. I am ashamed as a 'Bangladeshi' as this looting is happening on direct back up of the State's defense force for a very long time. I resemble myself in a position of Pakistani in 1971 and the indigenous people in place of 'Bangalees' and our national pride 'of no use'. BD army is doing the same thing what Pakistani army did in 1971. But our army is doing that for last couple of decades. I apologize to all 'Paharee' people as a human being.- Bhuiya Abddullah Al Faheem
We have to draw attention to the Bangladesh government to stop this violence.This is not acceptable for human behaviour.We have to protest internationally as much as we can.We hope that we will get support from various countries in the world.We have to fight the Bangladesh government to stop violence in CHT. Bangladesh government and Bengali people should not do such violence.l should say Bengali people have kindness for human beings.- Sa Ching Marma, Bangladesh
Please stop land grabbing and killing of Jumma people of CHTs. I appeal to the Hon'ble Prime Minister of Bangladesh to ensure peace and human security in CHTs. If Bangladesh government fails to do it, please ask UN for peace intervention in CHT.- Subhagya Mangal Chakma
This is a deplorable act perpetrated by people who don't care about the needs and welfare of others.This has been going on for ages and yet the past and present government is doing nothing to stop this.I personally condemn the act and request the government to give justice to these Jumma people. No body is above the law.-Anonymous
This is a barbaric act and gross violation of human rights and freedom for religious practice. I condemn this terrorist act. It is deplorable that even the State is not doing anything to resolve this problem.- Bibek Prasad Sharma
Please feel Buddhist, Islamic, Christian, Buddhist or other religion are human. Why different? We are in the same ground. We are in the same atmosphere. We breath the same air together. I don't know what you're thinking about Buddhist but all Buddhist are brothers and sisters. Please feel Buddhist....-Satthai Thanakorn, Thailand
Honorable PM, FM, HM, State M, Deputy Leader of JS, please implement CHTs Peace accord immediately with an action plan with time frame, send a parliamentary team at CHT to investigate the recent atrocity at Baghaihat and Khagrachai. Punish those who are responsible for this incident.- Dhiraj Chakma, Bangladesh
Shame on you for preying on the Chittagong people. We in America deeply regret our early experience with land grabs and inhuman treatment of original people. In the name of civilization, stop this travesty!- Barry Halgrimson
I don't understand why our Hon'ble Prime Minister who arranged to get the CHT Peace Accord-1997 signed is still keeping her silence on this horrific acts of violence. Why there is no order for judicial enquiry yet into this barbaric acts? I pray and hope that Democracy and Justice will prevail in Bangladesh.- Anonymous
Bangladesh is not in a situation it needs commit massacre in the name of national integration, intentional outsider-intrusion in the name of nation-building, nor anymore death in the name of security. I condemn the recent heinous incidents in CHT and appeal to get the responsible into justice leading to permanent peace in CHT. James Khakshi, Institute of Political Studies Bordeaux, France
I can't find the words to describe my deep concern about this tragic situation, the government has to take measures to protect the rights of Jumma people there. Otherwise, the whole world will boycott products from Bangladesh and take other drastic measures I am quite sure of it. -Berengere Desprez
I hope we shall read in the international newspapers of how the Bangledeshi Government has helped the poor and wronged and proved that they are the government of ALL Bangladeshis and not only of Bengalis. The greatness of a nation is proved by the tolerence shown to its minorities. Michael Prosser
With our bitter experiences with Pakistan for long time we cannot treat other ethnic people showing disrespect to their feelings and tradition and their way of life and make the same mistakes as Pakistani regime after regime did with us as we opposed to those and fought back vehemently in our long history! Immediate Implementation of Peace Treaty and meaningful Land reform is being URGENTLY needed to save the erupting situation! Do not try to marginalize ethnic people there with massive influx of other ethnic people to make them minority in their own backyard! That was wrong with us 40 years ago - that is wrong with CHT people today! We, the Bengali Nation cannot transfer the part of that oppression to our own people of the land! - Saleem Noor
The Fourth World Association of Sweden condemns attacks of this kind. All violation of human rights are unacceptable. The indigenous peoples of the Chittagong Hill Tracts must have their rights protected in every way by law, which is to be upheld by the governement of Bangladesh and its army, according to earlier agreements. - Henrik Persson, BA, Fourth World Association/Sweden
• Name: Gina Dizon on Feb 23, 2010
Comments: Stop grabbing Indigenous Peoples Lands! Justice to victims of the Baghaichari land grabbing!
• 2
Name: U Ravika on Feb 23, 2010
Comments: I understand how terrible the killing was. I came from Burma and my mother died in 1992. She was kicked, beaten, and aimed by guns by the Burmese soldiers. The house was stormed by them. Mon People have been lived in Burma thousands of year before the arrival of the Burmans. Burma is our homeland. We are treated as animals at our home. It is happening the same in Jumma-land. I saw Bangladesh the same as Burma. Let us stand together for our last stand.
• 3
Name: Ann Lily Marie O. Uvero on Feb 23, 2010
Comments: Please stop this, it derails all effort on the peace building being done.
• 4
Name: Saikat Biswas on Feb 23, 2010
Comments: One of the major indicators of good governance is that, 'how the minority and ethnic communities are living with free, fare, non-discriminate situation including enjoy their rights and dignity'. But what is a showing here? Ask your conscience.
• 5
Name: Ellen Bang-Oa on Feb 23, 2010
Comments:
• 6
Name: Arthur L. Allad-Iw on Feb 23, 2010
Comments:
• 7
Name: Mbaya Mulonzya on Feb 23, 2010
Comments:
• 8
Name: Dom-An Macagne on Feb 23, 2010
Comments: indigenous bamboo nose flute player from the Cordillera, Philippines
• 9
Name: Yvonne McPhee on Feb 23, 2010
Comments:
• 10
Name: Leticia Miana on Feb 23, 2010
Comments:
• 11
Name: Colin Nicholas on Feb 23, 2010
Comments: Madam PM: Please show your own people that you lead a civilized country.
• 12
Name: Robeliza Halip on Feb 23, 2010
Comments:
• 13
Name: Tom Cruise on Feb 23, 2010
Comments: Dear Madams\ Sirs, The Honorable Ministers, Especially Excellentcy Prime of the PEOPPLE REPUBLIC OF BANGLADESH, According to the election manifesto& 1997 peace accord it's required to remove the military from the HILL TRACKS; and the setlers, which they are occupying illigaly. Sincerely, TOM Cruise.
• 14
Name: Wasim Wagha on Feb 23, 2010
Comments: We, the indigenous peoples of Indus and tribal of Suleiman Mountains, are seriously concerned on the violence going on against the Juma peoples and demand the govt of Bangladesh to take notice and do justice with the tribal peoples by acknowledging their right to peace, livelhoods and identity.
• 15
Name: Shirin Lira on Feb 23, 2010
Comments: Stop supression and bloodshade
• 16
Name: Jiten Yumnam on Feb 23, 2010
Comments: Bangladesh seriously needs to respect and protect the human rights of indigenous peoples in CHT. The country should take urgent steps to stop encroaching on indigenous peoples land and to punish immediately those responsible in unleasing inhumanity and barbarism at its worst.
• 17
Name: Rumana Hashem on Feb 23, 2010
Comments: When words are lost I can't say much. But SILENCING PEOPLE MUST STOP!
• 18
Name: Alastair Henry on Feb 23, 2010
Comments:
• 19
Name: Paul Dudman on Feb 23, 2010
Comments:
• 20
Name: Ana Rubio Fernandez on Feb 23, 2010
Comments:
• 21
Name: Muktasree Chakma Sathi on Feb 23, 2010
Comments: pls, do as u promises. otherwise the people who supports u they will not do it anymore.
• 22
Name: Ashok K Chakma on Feb 23, 2010
Comments: Please act on stopping killing people in CHT without delay.
• 23
Name: Subrata Chakma on Feb 23, 2010
Comments: stop bloodshed and do justice.
• 24
Name: Joseph Surja on Feb 23, 2010
Comments:
• 25
Name: Rakhi Barua on Feb 23, 2010
Comments:
• 26
Name: Kazim Khan on Feb 23, 2010
Comments:
• 27
Name: Lina Lushai on Feb 23, 2010
Comments:
• 28
Name: Nasrin Siraj Annie on Feb 23, 2010
Comments:
• 29
Name: Maky Khisa on Feb 23, 2010
Comments:
• 30
Name: Tahsin Tareq Ahmad on Feb 23, 2010
Comments:
• 31
Name: Tahmina Hoque on Feb 23, 2010
Comments: I am not an indigeneous, but I can feel what is going upon them. please let us behave like human beings. Don't make any person homeless. Be afraid of acting like THE SUPREME BEING...........
• 32
Name: Midori Matsuda on Feb 23, 2010
Comments: Please stop violence, Please don't abuse power of Army injustice. Please respect / protect IP's peaceful life and rights.
• 33
Name: Eros Bonazzi on Feb 23, 2010
Comments: Please stop killing in CHT and investigate about present violences. Please, in the name of humanity!
• 34
Name: NEIKESANUO SORHIE on Feb 23, 2010
Comments:
• 35
Name: Mithila Mahfuz on Feb 23, 2010
Comments:
• 36
Name: NAGA PEOPLES' MOVEMENT FOR HUMAN RIGHTS, DELHI SECTOR on Feb 23, 2010
Comments:
• 37
Name: WOMEN AGAINST MILITARIZATION AND STATE VIOLENCE, THE OTHER MEDIA on Feb 23, 2010
Comments:
• 38
Name: Eva Turner on Feb 23, 2010
Comments:
• 39
Name: Tanuja Bhattacharjee on Feb 23, 2010
Comments:
• 40
Name: Karuna Priya on Feb 23, 2010
Comments: We want a FULL STOP to all this injustice and complete implementation of the CHT Peace Accord!
• 41
Name: Suresh Bikash Tanchangya on Feb 23, 2010
Comments: please stop grabbing jummaland and implement CHT peace accord. Let the people of CHT live in their lands in peace and harmony. Withdrew the army camps from CHT. Stop destroying Buddhist temples in CHT.
• 42
Name: Bhikkhu K Tanchangya on Feb 23, 2010
Comments: Let the jumma people live in peace in their own land. Implement the CHT peace accord so that peace would prevail in the hills.
• 43
Name: Nasrin Khandoker on Feb 23, 2010
Comments:
• 44
Name: S P Chakma on Feb 23, 2010
Comments: No more blood in CHT. No more Army in CHT. No more Settlers in CHT. Please remove the Settlers from CHT. We want peace.
• 45
Name: Marie-Claire Vlasblom on Feb 23, 2010
Comments:
• 46
Name: Pratang Chakma on Feb 23, 2010
Comments: চন্ডালের মতো হীন ও পাশবিক এ অত্যাচার ধরনী সইবেনা।যাদের তোমরা ফ্রাঙ্কেনস্টাইন হিসাবে গড়ে তুলছো তারাই একদিন বুমেরাং হবে।আজকের এ কথাটা মনে রেখো।
• 47
Name: Buddha Ratana Bhikkhu on Feb 23, 2010
Comments: We demand immediate action for it
• 48
Name: Dhiman Deb Chowdhury on Feb 23, 2010
Comments: We at HRCBM (http://www.hrcbm.org ) heart broken by the animosity of Bengali settlers and feel that state elements have failed to protect indigenous people of CHT. The allegation of Army’s involvement indicates state’s failure to uphold it’s constitution and it’s obligation under international law. This is an incidental proof of the ongoing genocide that long been ignore by the state as well the international community. It is thus imperative that state be hold responsible for such atrocities. Thanks Dhiman D Chowdhury President HRCBM http://www.hrcbm.org
• 49
Name: SAPTERSHI CHAKMA on Feb 23, 2010
Comments: my bloods are start boiling for recent activities of sattelar bangali in khagrachari and bhagaichari.and also to sheik hasina for her demcare in the CHT cricies.
• 50
Name: Roney on Feb 23, 2010
Comments: Protect bd army
• 51
• Name: Anonymous on Feb 23, 2010
Comments:
• 52
Name: Natalie Nolte on Feb 23, 2010
Comments:
• 53
Name: Souvik Chakma on Feb 23, 2010
Comments: We want Bengali settlers out of Chittagong Hill Tracts (CHT) and full implementation of 1997 CHT peace accord...in 1947 ethnic minorities counted for 97.5% of the population of CHT, in 1991 it was 51%, we are now minority in our own lands...govt. is sending bengalis from the plains to make us minority there... Bengalis backed by the army are taking away our lands either by force or by making false documents..they are torching our homes, temples and churches, raping and killing our people...land is not ours anymore.. Even the constitution of BAngladesh doesn't recognise our ethnicity, our cultures, our languages.. it's ETHNIC CLEANSING that is happening in CHT and we want the world to protest against it and protect us from being uprooted from our ancesteral lands. WE NEED YOUR HELP ! read the LIFE IS NOT OURS series by the international CHT commission to know more. u can get the copies here > http://www.chtcommission.org/?page_id=13 you y also read ETHNIC CLEANSING IN CHITTAGONG HILL TRACTS by Mr.SARADINDU SHEKHAR CHAKMA ISBN 984 464 164
• 54
Name: Anna Varney-Wong on Feb 23, 2010
Comments:
• 55
Name: Usurp Art Gallery &Amp; Studios on Feb 23, 2010
Comments:
• 56
Name: Anha Faruque Khan on Feb 23, 2010
Comments: Adibasi der somosto dabir sathe akatyota janacci.
• 57
Name: Russell Chakma on Feb 23, 2010
Comments:
• 58
Name: Atithi Chakma on Feb 23, 2010
Comments: Please take immediate action to save these people.......
• 59
Name: Patrick Kennedy on Feb 23, 2010
Comments:
• 60
Name: Md. Kayasul Islam on Feb 23, 2010
Comments: plz stop this ..................
• 61
Name: Anonymous on Feb 23, 2010
Comments: r 71 chai na. paharira amader bondhu-aponjon
• 62
Name: Yeasir Rahul on Feb 23, 2010
Comments: I support the cause of Jumma people wholeheartedly. And I apologize to them, on behalf of the Bangalis, for the injustice they are suffering for the last 50 years.
• 63
Name: Joo Myonghee on Feb 23, 2010
Comments: We Korean Buddhists are deeply sad by this news. We hope the Government of Bangladesh take necessary actions to fully implement the rights of the Jumma people as soon as possible.
• 64
Name: Amlan Chakma on Feb 23, 2010
Comments: Please save our people, land and Chittagong Hill TRcats by implementing CHT Accord.
• 65
Name: Abu Mustafiz on Feb 23, 2010
Comments: protibader vasha nai
• 66
Name: Bonney Hartley on Feb 23, 2010
Comments:
• 67
Name: Pinaki Roy on Feb 23, 2010
Comments: I strongly opposed, grabbing of Jumma People's land.
• 68
Name: SMITA CHAKMA on Feb 23, 2010
Comments: Hello, I dont want to say thousand words, dont want to do thousand request. This is such a crucial moment, such a situation no emotional sound gonna come out from my voice. Just want to say, BD is going to be destroy if the government is'nt initiative about whats happening inside. I pray the highest hell for all of those people who are involve in these brutality...
• 69
Name: Dilruba Sharmin on Feb 23, 2010
Comments:
• 70
Name: Dhiraj Debbarma on Feb 23, 2010
Comments: Really heart touching and indeed gross violation of human rights going out there..My only Appeal to the concerned authorities. Please be partial in your dealings and do something,before the situation goes out of control!
• 71
Name: Asta Mitkija Balto on Feb 23, 2010
Comments:
• 72
Name: SATYA TRIPURA on Feb 23, 2010
Comments:
• 73
Name: Dibos on Feb 23, 2010
Comments:
• 74
Name: Nabarun Chakma on Feb 23, 2010
Comments:
• 75
Name: Dr Bhagadatta Chakma on Feb 23, 2010
Comments: I can not comprehend the barbarity of your army and plain land settlers on the indegenous people of Chittagong Hill Tracts. As the head of a democratic government you are the responsible person and only you can stop and take action for these heinous acts. Our Jumma people supported all along your party and is this the prize for it Madam Prime Minister?
• 76
Name: Anonymous on Feb 23, 2010
Comments:
• 77
Name: Kabita Chakma on Feb 23, 2010
Comments:
• 78
Name: Piya Chakma on Feb 23, 2010
Comments:
• 79
Name: Joyoti Grech Cato on Feb 23, 2010
Comments: The time has come for Peace in the CHT. Sheikh Hasina, stop the killing. Remove troops. Provide emergency support to survivors.Return land to original inhabitants. Support the peaceful rule of law. Implement the CHT Peace Accord.
• 80
Name: Dr Bhagadatta Chakma on Feb 23, 2010
Comments: I can not comprehend the barbarity of your army and plain land settlers on the indegenous people of Chittagong Hill Tracts. As the head of a democratic government you are the responsible person and only you can stop and take action for these heinous acts. Our Jumma people supported all along your party and is this the prize for it Madam Prime Minister?
• 81
Name: Rahul Chakma John on Feb 23, 2010
Comments: humble request from UNO and Govt. of bangladesh to save indegenous CHAKMA.Now we people are helpless.As a nuatral party please try 2 overcome the problem.we want peace.
• 82
Name: Phanuthep Sutthithepthamrong on Feb 24, 2010
Comments:
• 83
Name: Phanuthep Sutthithepthamrong on Feb 24, 2010
Comments:
• 84
Name: Suchismita Roy on Feb 24, 2010
Comments:
• 85
Name: Shimul Chakma on Feb 24, 2010
Comments:
• 86
Name: Beth Mutton on Feb 24, 2010
Comments: I recently travelled to Bangladesh and specifically the Chittagong Hill Tracts area. It apalls me to know that the Bengali people are intent on staling land that does not belong to them, without any legal basis, and with the cost of the blood of thosae they are taking it from. Can you not see this is wrong? I met many people , Bengalis and indigenous people, and I know that they want this intermitent fighting to cease forever. Do not let this become another 1995. Resolve your problems without violence,and to the Bengalis- respect your neighbour, your country men, those who you fought alongside in the 1971 war, you are now turning against for the sake of greed!
• 87
Name: Hla Htay on Feb 24, 2010
Comments:
• 88
Name: Dalim Tanchangya on Feb 24, 2010
Comments: Please STOP killing in CHT. control Army & settlers ..... we want peace....
• 89
Name: Kolpon Chakma on Feb 24, 2010
Comments:
• 90
Name: Ruby Areng on Feb 24, 2010
Comments: Not only as a member of an Adibashi community also as a citizen of this country I strongly demand for the justice for the victims and urge to all to support us.
• 91
Name: Evelina Chakma on Feb 24, 2010
Comments:
• 92
Name: Evelina Chakma on Feb 24, 2010
Comments:
• 93
Name: Sourav Chakma on Feb 24, 2010
Comments:
• 94
Name: Ushaloy Chakma on Feb 24, 2010
Comments: Save us or declare war.
• 95
Name: Fatema Johara on Feb 24, 2010
Comments:
• 96
Name: Mir Mosharrof Hossain on Feb 24, 2010
Comments: please prime minister, save the humanity......dont through cht people to do establish their right with arms....act quickly.
• 97
Name: Prantik Chakma on Feb 24, 2010
Comments: it's really bad.our govt has no reaction about this. i hope govt. see this and take action who had done this.
• 98
Name: Md. Anisur Rahman on Feb 24, 2010
Comments: This is terrible.Bangladesh government should handle this massacre!
• 99
Name: Saydia Gulrukh on Feb 24, 2010
Comments: Bangladesh Army Out of Chittagong Hill Tracts..End Bengali Occupation NOW!!!
• 100
Name: Pranab Tanchangya on Feb 24, 2010
Comments: I am highly concerned about these current situations of CHITTAGONG HILL TRACTS jummo community. Due to present status many of debating against the fair events almost exposed and exposing which are driving people through wrong information and the main events are countered to be exposed clearly. i would like to tell every one that please observe the events carefully and explain all kinds of controversial topics clearly to others who are not clear about the situations. thank you all.
• 101
• Name: George Nokrek on Feb 24, 2010
Comments: stop violence in CHT.
• 102
Name: Nazneen Shifa on Feb 24, 2010
Comments:
• 103
Name: Sumaya Imam on Feb 24, 2010
Comments: Why these armies are always playing vindictive role to the Jumma? These irritable armies and Bengalis should be avert from the village and a threat for further of any mischief should be warn!
• 104
Name: Wasfia Nazreen on Feb 24, 2010
Comments:
• 105
Name: Trimita Chakma on Feb 24, 2010
Comments: I support the above petition.
• 106
Name: Anonymous on Feb 24, 2010
Comments: It is a great necessity that the present government of Bangladesh should implement the peace accord practically signed in 1997 and withdraw the military forces from the CHT, and establish DEMOCRACY. The Tribal people have come forward when Bangladesh was in need of during difficulties; they were also engaged in the war against Pakistan in 1971.
• 107
Name: Lobsang Tenzen on Feb 24, 2010
Comments: please put a stop to the killing of innocent people.
• 108
Name: S.Debbarma on Feb 24, 2010
Comments: Ms PM,Could you please stop this land grabbing act by the Muslim Bengalis.
• 109
Name: Uching Nue Chak on Feb 24, 2010
Comments:
• 110
Name: Bhuiya Abddullah Al Faheem on Feb 24, 2010
Comments: What happened in 'baghaichhari' is a shame for us as a human being. I personally feel ashamed as a 'Bangalee' as the Bangalee settlers are intruding by any means to lands from indigenous people. And i am ashamed as a 'Bangladeshi' as this looting is happening on direct back up of the state's defense force for a very long time. I resemble myself in a position of a Pakistani in 1971 and the indigenous people in place of 'bangalees' and our national pride and 'of no use' BD army is doing the same thing what pakistani army did in 1971; but our army is doing that for last couple of decades. I apologize to all 'Paharee' people as a human being.
• 111
Name: Jummo Changma on Feb 24, 2010
Comments: Any way you can protect against Bangalee Army SOB & Settler SOB
• 112
Name: Anonymous on Feb 24, 2010
Comments: Any way you can protect against Bangalee Army SOB & Settler SOB
• 113
Name: Ashraf Shishir on Feb 24, 2010
Comments: Stop Grabbing Jumma Land and Implement CHT Accord
• 114
Name: Effie Mats on Feb 24, 2010
Comments:
• 115
Name: Tunir on Feb 24, 2010
Comments: plz pay attention 2 dis prob, we r human2 nd none has da right2 treat us like dt.
• 116
Name: Joy Tripura on Feb 24, 2010
Comments:
• 117
Name: Hefzul Bari Ratul on Feb 24, 2010
Comments: Fight for justice....Fight for your rights....We are with you.
• 118
Name: Nayan Tanchangya on Feb 24, 2010
Comments: very bad behavior
• 119
Name: Malsawm Kim Irene on Feb 24, 2010
Comments:
• 120
Name: Shimul Barua on Feb 24, 2010
Comments: Please stop this cuelty and respect the minorities.
• 121
Name: Janet Naco on Feb 24, 2010
Comments:
• 122
Name: Toitum Chakma on Feb 24, 2010
Comments: Will you tolerate outsiders/settlers to your land or properties? I am sure no one will. Settlers/outsiders are destroying the living harmony in CHT, and its a shame for a nation that they are backed by the prestigeous military of our country.
• 123
Name: Ushino Marma on Feb 24, 2010
Comments: stop all......
• 124
Name: Mrinal M. Mrong C.S.C on Feb 24, 2010
Comments: Criminals are not belongs to any nation, religion and country.
• 125
Name: Umay Prue on Feb 24, 2010
Comments: save our community.........save our land.... lets make hand together.
• 126
Name: AUMI on Feb 24, 2010
Comments: SOLIDARITY!
• 127
Name: Suraporn Suriyamonton on Feb 24, 2010
Comments:
• 128
Name: Lina Lushai on Feb 24, 2010
Comments:
• 129
Name: Tally Dewan on Feb 24, 2010
Comments:
• 130
Name: Liya Chakma on Feb 24, 2010
Comments: By signing this ipetition I express my support to fellow jumma community and request government to take immediate actions to stop such violence. I would also request a fair investigation so that it does not happen in the future.
• 131
Name: Fahmidul Haq on Feb 24, 2010
Comments: Stop Grabbing Jumma Land and Implement CHT Accord
• 132
Name: Shyamal Kanti Barman on Feb 24, 2010
Comments: We must stand right now by the Jumma people of CHT. Their problems should be resolved politically.
• 133
Name: Rana Chakma on Feb 24, 2010
Comments: I urge all the peace loving people of the world to condemn this atrocious killings of the Indigenous people of the Chittagong Hill Tracts, committed by the Bengali settlers. Also please circulate this link to as many contacts as possible with a request to do the same.
• 134
Name: Richard Solly on Feb 24, 2010
Comments:
• 135
Name: Mithel Chakma on Feb 24, 2010
Comments: Just couldn't stop tear-drops after reading it and seeing the photos. Please stop this kind of barbaric act forever in CHT. We want peace and communal-harmony. Bangladesh Govt. must take immediate action to find out the culprits for punishment.
• 136
Name: Santanu Dey on Feb 24, 2010
Comments:
• 137
Name: Jed Medel Laurito on Feb 24, 2010
Comments: I am saddened by the atrocities...one with the Jumma people in their struggle for territorial rights.
• 138
Name: Promud Sinha on Feb 24, 2010
Comments: Please stop these kind of inhuman activities and save the innocent lives there. This should not be repeated in future. We're all brothers and sisters whether it is minor or major. And the culprits must be well punished
• 139
Name: Richard Edkins on Feb 24, 2010
Comments:
• 140
Name: Polly on Feb 24, 2010
Comments: Shame for nation or Humanity
• 141
Name: Rocktim Dewan on Feb 24, 2010
Comments:
• 142
Name: Oinam Lanthoy on Feb 24, 2010
Comments: please stop grabbing jummaland and implement CHT peace accord. Let the people of CHT live in their lands in peace and harmony. Stop destroying Buddhist temples in CHT.
• 143
Name: Abhoy Prakash Chakma on Feb 24, 2010
Comments: The Govt. of Bangladsh will have to preserve us by forming a safe place like sanctaurium to save our different culture, ethnic diversity and there is no way except regional autnomy.
• 144
Name: Shanawez on Feb 24, 2010
Comments: Plz world community stop it
• 145
• Name: Evelina Chakma on Feb 24, 2010
Comments:
• 146
Name: Didarul Alam on Feb 24, 2010
Comments: niceeeeee
• 147
Name: Helen Lowe on Feb 24, 2010
Comments:
• 148
Name: Raymond Areng on Feb 24, 2010
Comments: I demand immediate and appropriate measures against those who made the Jummu people helpless from the government.
• 149
Name: Ashis Kumar Chakma on Feb 24, 2010
Comments:
• 150
Name: Pratiti Chakma on Feb 24, 2010
Comments:
• 151
• Name: Raphael on Feb 24, 2010
Comments: i m with u.
• 152
Name: Debasish Debu on Feb 24, 2010
Comments: `jollader ai ullas moncho amar desh noy.' kshoma koro paharer bondura, amiO 1jon bangali.
• 153
Name: Shibayan on Feb 24, 2010
Comments: Stop this ethnic cleansing and restore rights for the Hill tribes.
• 154
Name: Aparna Howlader on Feb 24, 2010
Comments: Agree with the petition .
• 155
Name: Tanu Murang on Feb 24, 2010
Comments: Bring the culprits in to justice
• 156
Name: Jennifer Harkonen on Feb 24, 2010
Comments:
• 157
Name: Romel Chakma on Feb 24, 2010
Comments: Please Save our lives........
310
Name: Graeme Tully on Mar 4, 2010 Comments: Please respect the Jumma people and implement the CHT Accord. Your behaviour is viewed as monstrous by the ordinary person.
Comments: As former Bangladeshi, I'm appalled to hear how Bangladesh treats their own citizens. In a changing world, our indigenous tribes are the only ones to show us how to live in harmony with our world again.
Comments: I am utterly disgusted by the actions of the settlers, aided and protected by the army. Indigenous peoples rights must be respected, they have lived there for countless generations and must be allowed to remain there in peace. An independent inquiry into these incidents must be conducted as soon as possible and those responsible, including army personnel, brought to justice.
Comments: Please stop immediately the brutal, inhumane and unjustified attacks on these innocent people who simply just want to carry on living in their homes harming no one
Comments: We don't want to see this happend again on the soil of CHT. The govt of Bangladesh must respect the accord which they signed 12 years ago. As per the accord they must first and foremost have to withdraw all army camps from CHT; and the govt must solve land problems as per recommendations of CHT Jumma leaders. The govt should consider EU proposal with regard to assisting resettlement of Bengali settlers from CHT to elsewhere in Bangladesh. If the govt is really intend to establish peace in the CHT's soil then they must take courageous actions of above soon.
Comments: These abominations and acts of attempted Genocide against the Jumma People must end now and CHT accord fully and immeditaely implemented, and any acts of aggression be dealt with under strict observance of laws against Genocide. This cannot continue any longer. It is wrong for humans to treat eachother so and there can be no excuse for such barbaric and animalistic acts such as these. yours sincerely. Michael Clay.